Skip to content

Airline Regulations Should be Grounded

In August, new air­line reg­u­la­tions from the U.S. gov­ern­ment will go into effect. They include refunding pas­sen­gers checked bag fees if lug­gage is lost, increasing the com­pen­sa­tion bumped pas­sen­gers receive and imposing time limits on how long planes making inter­na­tional flights can wait on the tarmac. Steven Mor­rison, pro­fessor and chair of the Depart­ment of Eco­nomics at North­eastern Uni­ver­sity, who studies the air­line industry, exam­ines these reg­u­la­tions and the state of the air­line industry since the eco­nomic downturn.

What is your take on these new regulations?

My gen­eral reac­tion is that the pri­mary poli­cies that the gov­ern­ment should pursue regarding air­lines is not to specify how they should treat pas­sen­gers in cer­tain instances, but rather to make sure there is suf­fi­cient com­pe­ti­tion, and thus choice for pas­sen­gers. That way, pas­sen­gers can vote with their wal­lets about which air­line poli­cies they prefer and which to pay for.

Air­lines were dereg­u­lated in 1978, ending the government’s authority over spec­i­fying what fares they could charge and which routes they could run. But there is always this notion, in all phases of life, that, “There ought to be a law.” Air­lines are no dif­ferent than any other industry. It’s more impor­tant to ensure there is com­pe­ti­tion and let the market work, and make sure con­sumers have all the infor­ma­tion they need to make deci­sions for themselves.

Are air­lines charging cus­tomers more fees nowa­days than in years past?

There are more fees now because the product has become unbun­dled. You used to be able to book flights that would come with food, checked bags and your choice of any seat in coach. Now you pay more for food or a seat with more legroom. Air­lines call it “a la carte” pricing, and it’s under­stand­able for air­lines to issue these charges in their scramble to gen­erate as much rev­enue as pos­sible in an uncer­tain eco­nomic envi­ron­ment.  But it’s impor­tant that pas­sen­gers know what they’re get­ting charged for.

What is the state of the air­line industry’s finan­cial situation?

They are cer­tainly doing better. The pri­mary long­standing problem the air­line industry has faced is aligning capacity with demand over the busi­ness cycle. What typ­i­cally hap­pens in an eco­nomic down­turn is the air­lines are stuck with too much capacity. So they will offer dis­counts. Then the economy turns around, and air­lines aggres­sively add seats and end up with too much capacity again. But over the last sev­eral years, air­lines have been extremely dis­ci­plined with capacity addi­tions and taking capacity out of ser­vice. So fares are going up sig­nif­i­cantly because the economy is improving and air­lines have been retrained regarding capacity. In addi­tion, fuel prices are now rising.

Summer is the peak plea­sure travel season, and fares are gen­er­ally lower during this time of year. But they will be higher than they have been in past sum­mers for these rea­sons I’ve mentioned.

– by Greg St. Martin

More Stories

Photo of the Capitol Building at night

High stakes for politics, SCOTUS in 2018

Photo of the crashed truck that was used in the October 31st attack in Manhattan.

Weaponizing Language: How the meaning of “allahu akbar” has been distorted

Northeastern logo

Why I love studying Spanish