Skip to content

Censorship’s impact on Chinese culture

China’s Min­istry of Cul­ture recently man­dated removing 100 songs from web­sites across the country in an effort to pre­serve China’s “national cul­tural secu­rity.” The list con­sists largely of tracks by Hong Kong and Tai­wanese artists, but also includes hits from Amer­ican pop icons such as Lady Gaga, Bey­oncé and the Back­street Boys. The min­istry claims the banned songs weren’t sub­mitted for manda­tory gov­ern­ment screening and haven’t been approved for dis­tri­b­u­tion. We asked Hua Dong, a fac­ulty member in Northeastern’s Asian Studies Pro­gram and an expert on Chi­nese pop cul­ture, to ana­lyze gov­ern­ment cen­sor­ship and its impact on Chi­nese cul­ture.

Why does the Chi­nese gov­ern­ment believe that music from cer­tain Amer­ican pop stars poses a threat to China’s national cul­tural secu­rity?

This example demon­strates another attempt by the Chi­nese gov­ern­ment to rein in the fast growing Internet in the country. China now has almost 500 mil­lion Internet users, mostly young, edu­cated and wealthy, who spend the majority of their online time using social net­working sites and micro-​​blogging. Internet is cen­tral to the lives of China’s Neti­zens. It is an impor­tant venue for accessing enter­tain­ment and infor­ma­tion, and it is an effec­tive tool for social activism. One recent example is a protest last month attended by 12,000 micro-​​bloggers that suc­cess­fully forced the local gov­ern­ment to shut down a toxic chem­ical fac­tory in Dalian, a Chi­nese coastal city. The take­away mes­sage from the event for the Chi­nese web cen­sors might be that infor­ma­tion must be con­trolled and the Internet should be cleansed of any “poor taste and vulgar con­tent.” China’s Cul­tural Min­istry may find the rebel­lious and defiant nature of pop songs threat­ening to the “social har­mony” that the gov­ern­ment is trying to pro­mote.

More gen­er­ally, how do bans like this affect Chi­nese cul­ture, media con­sump­tion and the country’s youth?

When I first learned of the Cul­tural Ministry’s “black­list,” I reached out to a few friends in China who are either active in China’s cul­ture scenes or serve as cul­tural offi­cials them­selves. Inter­est­ingly, none of them were even aware of the new reg­u­la­tion. They con­tinue to use Weibo (a Chi­nese ver­sion of Twitter) and check Renren (a Chi­nese ver­sion of Face­book) as before. I then checked some Chi­nese web­sites, and found a growing cyn­i­cism filling the blogs. Bans like this are not enough to silence people into com­pli­ance in the 21st cen­tury.

Ai Weiwei, a Chi­nese artist, also recently made head­lines again for his scathing attack on the gov­ern­ment in Newsweek since being released from deten­tion. What has the public reac­tion in China his­tor­i­cally been to those such as Mr. Ai who crit­i­cize the gov­ern­ment and cen­sor­ship?

Ai Weiwei, who has nearly a hun­dred thou­sand fol­lowers on his new Twitter ser­vice since his release, has achieved huge name recog­ni­tion in China. His release was met with warm wel­come and sup­port from the Neti­zens in China. How­ever, this sup­port and aware­ness is still con­sid­er­ably small within the large Chi­nese pop­u­la­tion. Out­side the small circle of Chi­nese intel­lec­tuals, the Chi­nese public cares about the same things as any typ­ical Amer­ican — buying a car and a house, job secu­rity, afford­able med­ical care, better schools for their chil­dren and so on. Many blog­gers are not inter­ested in pro­moting polit­ical change, yet remain pas­sionate about having the right to express their opin­ions about topics that interest them. The government’s pros­e­cu­tion of dis­si­dents tends to fall off the radar for those who mainly endeavor for a better life in a fast-​​evolving society.

– by Lauren Dibble

More Stories

Photo of the Capitol Building at night

High stakes for politics, SCOTUS in 2018

Photo of the crashed truck that was used in the October 31st attack in Manhattan.

Weaponizing Language: How the meaning of “allahu akbar” has been distorted

Northeastern logo

Why I love studying Spanish