Skip to content

How, and why, some Jewish scholars were left behind

During the 1930s and early 1940s, fac­ulty posi­tions offered by Amer­ican uni­ver­si­ties served as one of the few life­lines for hun­dreds of thou­sands of scholars trying to flee war-​​torn Europe to escape per­se­cu­tion. Yet far too often, the uni­ver­si­ties didn’t do enough to save these refugees and even offered chill­ingly dis­mis­sive rea­sons for not doing so, according to Laurel Leff, asso­ciate pro­fessor in the School of Jour­nalism and the Bernard A. Stotsky Pro­fessor of Jewish His­tor­ical and Cul­tural Studies at Northeastern.

Leff deliv­ered the keynote address Monday morning at the annual North­eastern Holo­caust Com­mem­o­ra­tion, held in the Raytheon Amphithe­ater. This year, the event was also part of a new edu­ca­tional series on civic sus­tain­ability—Con­flict. Civility. Respect. Peace. North­eastern Reflects.”—pre­sented by the Col­lege of Social Sci­ences and Human­i­ties with the Office of Stu­dent Affairs. The North­eastern Holo­caust Com­mem­o­ra­tion was the first in a series of events for Holo­caust Aware­ness Week.

“The United States’ role in saving Europe’s intel­lec­tual elite from the Nazis is often told as a tri­umphalist tale,” Leff said. “But in many ways, it is not a tale of tri­umph because for every per­se­cuted intel­lec­tual we saved, many more tried to escape but couldn’t.”

Six mil­lion Jews were killed during the Holo­caust, and Leff said that very little atten­tion has been paid to exploring why so many couldn’t escape. She called the refugee crisis “the cen­tral moral dilemma of the 1930s and the early 1940s.” She is a former news­paper reporter whose book Buried by The Times: The Holo­caust and America’s Most Impor­tant News­paper was pub­lished in 2005.

Leff’s talk focused on Amer­ican uni­ver­si­ties not only because they could cir­cum­vent immi­gra­tion quotas by offering refugees fac­ulty posi­tions, but also because aca­d­e­mics and pro­fes­sionals were among the first to be dis­placed by the Nazi regime. In addi­tion, she said Amer­ican aca­d­emic elites had the strongest ties to Europe and there­fore a better under­standing of the problem.

Refugee pro­fes­sors typ­i­cally received two-​​year appoint­ments at Amer­ican uni­ver­si­ties, and those posi­tions were funded by out­side orga­ni­za­tions. Leff said uni­ver­si­ties largely viewed the deci­sion to save refugees as strictly a hiring job appli­ca­tion process, and they based their deci­sions on a range of cri­teria. Intel­lec­tual elites were the ones pri­marily offered fac­ulty posi­tions. In the uni­ver­si­ties’ defense, Leff acknowl­edged that many were wor­ried about how they would pay these pro­fes­sors once those terms expired, par­tic­u­larly in the eco­nomic cli­mate fol­lowing the Great Depression.

How­ever, Leff said her research uncov­ered wide­spread anti-​​Semitic sen­ti­ment and some chilling lan­guage in let­ters, memos, writ­ings, and other records related to the dis­missals of Jewish pro­fes­sors. Phrases like “too Jewish,” “run of the mill,” “mediocre,” and “not first rate” were reg­u­larly used when making hiring choices. Leff cited numerous exam­ples from East Coast universities—including Har­vard Uni­ver­sity, Dart­mouth Col­lege, and Boston University.

Leff also cited an example from North­eastern that ref­er­enced a memo from then soon to be pres­i­dent Carl S. Ell, who was weighing whether to hire a Jewish pro­fessor from Hun­gary. The two had a 90-​​minute con­ver­sa­tion, fol­lowing which Ell wrote a note to file in which he made anti-​​Semitic com­ments and ques­tioned the value the scholar could bring to Northeastern.

The memo was dis­cov­ered in Northeastern’s library archives fol­lowing Leff’s request during her research. When the finding first came to light, Pres­i­dent Joseph E. Aoun imme­di­ately requested the entire archives be mined for other exam­ples of prej­u­dice. This work has been under­taken by William Wakeling, dean of Uni­ver­sity Libraries, and Dis­tin­guished Pro­fessor of His­tory William Fowler.

After the pre­sen­ta­tion, Aoun praised Leff for the rigor of her research and under­scored the impor­tance of trans­parency on the issue. Aoun added that the Ell note serves as an indi­vidual example of what the Holo­caust Com­mem­o­ra­tion is all about—“making sure that we never, ever forget.”

In Feb­ruary, Aoun announced the for­ma­tion of the Pres­i­den­tial Council on Inclu­sion and Diver­sity, which has been fol­lowed by the year­long series “Con­flict. Civility. Respect. Peace. North­eastern Reflects.” He said Monday’s Holo­caust Com­mem­o­ra­tion con­tinued the growing dia­logue on campus.

Prior to Leff’s keynote address, Lori Lefkovitz, Rud­erman Pro­fessor, director of the Jewish Studies pro­gram, and a pro­fessor of Eng­lish, intro­duced the day’s stu­dent speaker: Heather Viola. A third-​​year inter­na­tional affairs and human ser­vices com­bined major with a minor in Jewish Studies, Viola received the 2012–13 Gideon Klein schol­ar­ship, which sup­ports a stu­dent exploring the work of a Jewish artist or musi­cian per­se­cuted by the Nazis.

Viola opened her talk by beau­ti­fully singing in German the lul­laby “Wie­gala,” orig­i­nally com­posed by Ilse Weber. Weber and her family were deported to Terezin, a con­cen­tra­tion camp in the hills out­side Prague. There, she became a nurse and con­tinued to write new songs to inspire, teach, and nur­ture the thou­sands of chil­dren who were sent there. Through her research, Viola explained how she became fas­ci­nated with Terezin’s his­tory and the role music played in the lives of detainees—one of whom was Gideon Klein himself.

“[Music] was the tool through which people expe­ri­enced and sur­vived their reality,” said Viola, who is a soprano in the North­eastern Choral Society and the Zamir Chorale of Boston. Music, she explained, is a means of con­necting with her own spir­i­tu­ality and religion.

Holo­caust Aware­ness Week pro­gram­ming con­tinued Monday after­noon with the 21st Annual Robert Salomon Morton Lec­ture by author Daniel Mendel­sohn. An award-​​winning writer, he penned the 2006 best­seller The Lost: A Search for Six of Six Mil­lion fol­lowing years of research into the his­tory of six of his rel­a­tives in Poland. Mendelsohn’s talk explored that his­tory, and how over the years, some of the details he’s received first­hand and from written doc­u­men­ta­tion and sur­vivor inter­views have changed the narrative.

With respect to the Holo­caust, he called this a “hinge moment”—at which point an event is in the process of passing from the lived expe­ri­ence con­tained in the living mem­o­ries of the par­tic­i­pants into recorded his­tory. In other words, from oral nar­ra­tive into written documentation.

“This moment that we live in now is of course that moment … when the last sur­vivors and wit­nesses are dis­ap­pearing, and there­fore that moment when their sto­ries are grad­u­ally changing hands and becoming the pos­ses­sion of people like me, who track those sur­vivors down and pre­serve those sto­ries for other people,” Mendel­sohn told an audi­ence gath­ered in the audi­to­rium of 20 West Vil­lage F.

Holo­caust Aware­ness Week pro­gram­ming con­tinues Tuesday at noon in the Raytheon Amphithe­ater, where author Matthew Brzezinski will dis­cuss the myth of pas­sivity during the Holo­caust by showing that resis­tance was far more wide­spread than is gen­er­ally acknowledged.

Visit the North­eastern Human­i­ties Center web­site for more details about the all the Holo­caust Aware­ness Week pro­gram­ming.

– by Greg St. Martin

More Stories

Photo of the Capitol Building at night

High stakes for politics, SCOTUS in 2018

Photo of the crashed truck that was used in the October 31st attack in Manhattan.

Weaponizing Language: How the meaning of “allahu akbar” has been distorted

Northeastern logo

Why I love studying Spanish