Skip to content

A legal battle over family land

Peter Sonnenthal

Peter Son­nen­thal, L’83, has been locked in a pro­tracted legal battle in the German courts for more than 20 years, hoping to recover prop­erty that belonged to his Jewish ancestors.

Peter Son­nen­thal, L’83, has been locked in a pro­tracted legal battle in the German courts for more than 20 years, hoping to recover prop­erty that belonged to his Jewish ancestors.

He dis­cussed the case on Wednesday after­noon at North­eastern University’s School of Law, deliv­ering a lec­ture titled “That Land was My Family’s Land: A Legal and His­tor­ical Struggle Against Nazi Crimes.” Some three-​​dozen people attended the event, which was co-​​sponsored by the School of Law; the School of Jour­nalism; the Jewish Studies pro­gram; and the Holo­caust Aware­ness Committee.

At stake in Sonnenthal’s case is roughly 200 acres of farm­land in the upscale Berlin suburb of Teltow. Sonnenthal’s great-​​grandfather, Albert Sabersky, and his brother, Max, pur­chased the prop­erty in 1872 and devel­oped the land into a multimillion-​​dollar holding. The value of the land reached $100 mil­lion by 1933, when Hitler came to power and a so-​​called “Aryaniser” report­edly forced the family to sign a con­tract giving the town of Teltow approx­i­mately one-​​third of the property.

My ances­tors were stripped of their land during the Nazi regime through anti-​​Semitic laws,” Son­nen­thal con­tends, noting that his past life as a lawyer for the U.S. Secu­ri­ties and Exchange Com­mis­sion pre­pared him for his fight to reclaim his family’s land. “One day, in light of all the evi­dence, I hope my efforts to obtain a full mea­sure of jus­tice will be seen as responsible.”

Sonnenthal’s resti­tu­tion battle began in 1991, fol­lowing the fall of the Berlin Wall and German reuni­fi­ca­tion. Although he reclaimed some of his family’s plots, German author­i­ties rejected the majority of his claim, ruling in 1996 that his ances­tors had not sold the prop­erty under duress.

Undaunted by the ruling, Son­nen­thal con­tinued to build his case, cre­ating a com­pre­hen­sive “net­work of infor­ma­tion.” His­tor­ical maps of his family’s land proved to be a par­tic­u­larly invalu­able resource, he said, adding that “the research is never com­plete and there are always more leads to follow.”

Son­nen­thal appealed the deci­sion and even­tu­ally moved to Ger­many in 2002 to work on the case, which has wended its way through a labyrinth of German courts for the past 23 years. The lit­i­ga­tion process dragged on, and the two judges pre­siding over the case since 1996—Wilfried Hamm and Peter Pfennig—seemed, in Sonnenthal’s view, to be bent on denying jus­tice. “They were not pro­fes­sionals,” Son­nen­thal said, “and they used their fact-​​finding duties to dis­tort my family’s history.”

After years of failed appeals, Sonnenthal’s painstaking devo­tion to his case appeared to have paid off: In 2003, the Fed­eral Admin­is­tra­tive Court ruled that his ances­tors had indeed sold this prop­erty under duress from the Nazis and, in 2005, the German fed­eral gov­ern­ment agreed to a set­tle­ment. But the vic­tory was short-​​lived.

Since 2006, the town of Teltow has chal­lenged the fed­eral ruling and sought to block Son­nen­thal from building duplexes on the unused land. The local gov­ern­ment fought the nego­ti­ated set­tle­ment by reviving the case’s well-​​worn argu­ment, claiming that the Saber­skys did not face per­se­cu­tion by the Nazis and did indeed relin­quish their land of their own accord.

Last month, the legal saga took yet another unusual turn. In a stroke of good for­tune for Son­nen­thal, Hamm and Pfennig were removed from the case. “[They] were truly not well-​​intentioned,” he said. “As a result, some­thing that could have been resolved fast and prop­erly has not been.”

Although the inter­minable case has caused him and his family great anguish, Son­nen­thal does not harbor any ill will toward Ger­many. “I don’t dis­pute Germany’s deep and abiding com­mit­ment to Holo­caust sur­vivors,” he said. “To heal,” he added, through tears, “I had to for­give Germany.”

More Stories

Photo of the Capitol Building at night

High stakes for politics, SCOTUS in 2018

Photo of the crashed truck that was used in the October 31st attack in Manhattan.

Weaponizing Language: How the meaning of “allahu akbar” has been distorted

Northeastern logo

Why I love studying Spanish