Skip to content
Topics
Stories

Preventing protests from turning violent

Riots erupted in London and throughout Eng­land ear­lier this month, exposing a broad dis­con­tent among Britain’s dis­ad­van­taged youth. We spoke with Gor­dana Rabren­ovic, asso­ciate pro­fessor of soci­ology and edu­ca­tion, and the asso­ciate director of the Brud­nick Center on Vio­lence and Con­flict, to dis­cuss what caused the riots and why the young people in Britain turned to violence.

What caused these riots, and how can the U.K. pre­vent sim­ilar inci­dents from occurring?

According to U.K. media reports, the riots were ini­tially caused by the London police’s mis­han­dling of the after­math of the shooting death of 29-​​year-​​old Mark Duggan in a poor north London neigh­bor­hood. The police failed to com­mu­ni­cate with Duggan’s family about his death in a timely manner, causing 200 people to gather out­side the local police sta­tion seeking answers. This gath­ering turned into a riot that esca­lated into looting, and quickly spread to other London neigh­bor­hoods and later to other major cities. Par­tic­i­pants in the rioting were ini­tially young males, but other groups of people soon joined in as well. It appears the riots were orches­trated by social media users through Twitter, Face­book and Black­Berry Messenger.

In the begin­ning, police were slow to react to the riots, appar­ently sur­prised by how quickly they spread and by the number of par­tic­i­pants. This expe­ri­ence sug­gests that one of the best ways to pro­tect neigh­bor­hoods from vio­lence in the future is to strengthen police-​​community rela­tion­ships and com­mu­ni­ca­tion. Police need to forge strong com­mu­nity rela­tions if they are to respond with the speed required to meet the chal­lenges pre­sented by evolving social media technology.

Are acts of public dis­cord (such as protests, picket lines, and riots) an effec­tive means to an end?

Protest is a legit­i­mate strategy and some­times the only strategy pow­er­less people have to fight for their rights. A lack of polit­ical power and finan­cial resources can force groups to use the power of their num­bers to make their con­cerns known. The sheer number of people that par­tic­i­pate in such events often attracts media atten­tion and can help make the plight of a par­tic­ular group more vis­ible to the gen­eral population.

How­ever, when protest esca­lates into vio­lence and looting, the protesting group often loses its legit­i­macy. The London riots show how easily social order can break down. Protests that do not turn to rioting and looting are much more likely to address the pro­tes­tors’ concerns.

Why do some pop­u­la­tions, such as youth or mar­gin­al­ized groups, resort to rioting, rather than taking formal or peaceful avenues?

They lack social infra­struc­ture, such as com­mu­nity orga­ni­za­tions to artic­u­late their demands, or polit­ical and eco­nomic resources to pursue formal avenues. Riots allow them to vent their anger, and looting gives them an oppor­tu­nity to obtain goods they cannot afford. In addi­tion, looting, which is a mostly non­vi­o­lent act, can attract a wider pop­u­la­tion that oppor­tunis­ti­cally takes advan­tage of a gen­eral state of law­less­ness for per­sonal gain.

The ulti­mate chal­lenge for the U.K. is to develop a public col­lec­tive effi­cacy that pre­vents sim­ilar inci­dents from occur­ring. It also needs to con­sider how best to address the social, eco­nomic and polit­ical mar­gin­al­iza­tion of youth in its cities. This will require devel­op­ment of part­ner­ships between police and the com­mu­nity, sim­ilar to the ones Boston has devel­oped. It will also require investing in edu­ca­tion and social pro­grams that give young people more of a stake in their community.

– by Greg St. Martin

 

More Stories

Racial justice protests were not a major cause of COVID-19 infection surges, new national study finds

08.11.2020

Here’s what could happen if the U.S. suspends federal pandemic unemployment benefits

08.10.2020

Black women asked their party for what they wanted. What happens next?

08.13.20
In the News