Skip to content

The dilemma of U.S. military intervention

Retired Gen. David D. McK­iernan, the former com­mander of U.S. and NATO forces in Afghanistan, used the familiar New Eng­land imagery of a lob­ster pot to describe the ram­i­fi­ca­tions of U.S. mil­i­tary inter­ven­tion in con­flicts on for­eign soil.

“Easy to get in,” but “hard to get out,” he told a packed Raytheon Amphithe­ater at North­eastern Uni­ver­sity on Thursday evening.

The event, enti­tled “U.S. Mil­i­tary Inter­ven­tions, Pre– and Post-​​9/​11,” aligned with Northeastern’s com­mit­ment to national secu­rity and the goal of fos­tering dis­cus­sions of great global impor­tance. It was co-​​sponsored by the Office of the Pres­i­dent and Col­lege of Social Sci­ences and Human­i­ties.

Throughout the 90-​​minute, candid dis­cus­sion McK­iernan stressed that U.S. mil­i­tary inven­tion should be a last resort in responding to inter­na­tional con­flicts. He said Amer­ican polit­ical leaders must also place a greater pri­ority on under­standing the his­tory, cul­ture and com­plex social struc­ture of those regions, in addi­tion to the diver­sity of people living there. Those steps, he said, weren’t given proper con­sid­er­a­tion before America sent troops to Iraq and Afghanistan in the wake of the Sept. 11 attacks.

McK­iernan urged stu­dents in atten­dance to keep these con­sid­er­a­tions in mind as they pre­pare to begin careers in which they’ll be required to make impor­tant decisions.

“It requires the intel­lec­tual energy of every­body to make good deci­sions,” he said. “We’ve made some good deci­sions, and we’ve made some bad deci­sions. Under­standing the envi­ron­ment is key to making those good deci­sions.” After his lec­ture, McK­iernan fielded ques­tions posed by audi­ence mem­bers on topics such as the use of drones in combat, applying lessons learned from past con­flicts to cur­rent dilemmas and the finan­cial costs of war.

McK­iernan, the former com­mander for the Inter­na­tional Secu­rity Assis­tance Force in Afghanistan, entered the Army in 1972 with an ROTC com­mis­sion and com­manded sol­diers at every rank from second lieu­tenant to four-​​star gen­eral. His dis­tin­guished 37-​​year U.S. Army career included ser­vice in the Gulf War, Korea, Europe and the Balkans, South­west Asia, Iraq and Afghanistan.

McK­iernan led all ground forces into Iraq during Oper­a­tion Iraqi Freedom in 2002-​​03, removing Saddam Hus­sein and the Baath Party from power with a 160,000 joint and coali­tion for­ma­tion. In his final com­mand assign­ment in 2008-​​09 in Afghanistan, he was respon­sible for more than 100,000 sol­diers, sailors, airmen, Marines and Spe­cial Forces in both a NATO ISAF (including 42 con­tributing nations) and U.S. Oper­a­tion Enduring Freedom role.

In his Thursday evening dis­cus­sion, McK­iernan focused on U.S. mil­i­tary inter­ven­tions in Iraq and Afghanistan, but also touched on Amer­i­cans’ pres­ence in both mil­i­tary and peace-​​keeping roles dating back to the Cold War and in places such as Kuwait, Panama and Kosovo.

“It’s a much more com­plex, ambiguous, divi­sive world when you decide to go in and inter­vene some­where and change the status quo, change the existing order,” he said.

He added, “Unless we’re willing to pledge a siz­able of amount of resources to commit mil­i­tary for a long period of time, I’m talking gen­er­a­tions, there won’t be a lasting impact, espe­cially if there’s not pop­ular sup­port in the area where we’ve intervened.”

Ear­lier in the day, McK­iernan engaged more than 50 people for a seminar-​​style lec­ture focused on Afghanistan, which he described as a country with a “mosaic” of people who’ve lived through a his­tory of con­tinual con­flict — one that has trau­ma­tized its social fabric and bred a cul­ture of violence.

The seminar’s audi­ence com­prised of fac­ulty, staff, ROTC cadets, mem­bers of the Stu­dent Vet­erans Asso­ci­a­tion and under­grad­uate stu­dents in the “Inter­na­tional Con­flict and Nego­ti­a­tion” course taught by Kim­berly Jones, fac­ulty asso­ciate in the Middle East Center for Peace, Cul­ture and Devel­op­ment and head adviser in the Inter­na­tional Affairs pro­gram and Middle East Studies.

At the after­noon dis­cus­sion, Georges Van Den Abbeele, founding dean of the Col­lege of Social Sci­ences and Human­i­ties, high­lighted McKiernan’s dis­tin­guished career and wel­comed him back to campus. McK­iernan served as the keynote speaker at Northeastern’s Vet­erans Day cer­e­mony in 2011 hon­oring those who have served and pro­tected our country.

Van Den Abbeele also noted Northeastern’s com­mit­ment to lead­er­ship in national-​​security efforts, including its long­standing com­mit­ment to the ROTC pro­gram.

“I saw first hand the tremen­dous exper­tise and expe­ri­ence Gen­eral McK­iernan can bring to the uni­ver­sity com­mu­nity, and par­tic­u­larly to the Col­lege of Social Sci­ences and Human­i­ties, when I heard him speak on campus last fall,” Van Den Abbeele said. “He did not dis­ap­point in Pro­fessor Jones’ class this morning. Our stu­dents had the unique oppor­tu­nity to learn from and engage with one of the most dis­tin­guished com­man­ders of our times, a strategic thinker whose grasp of the global chal­lenges we face today is simply unparalleled.”

– by Greg St. Martin

More Stories

Photo of the Capitol Building at night

High stakes for politics, SCOTUS in 2018

Photo of the crashed truck that was used in the October 31st attack in Manhattan.

Weaponizing Language: How the meaning of “allahu akbar” has been distorted

Northeastern logo

Why I love studying Spanish