Skip to content

‘West Memphis Three’ set free

Three men in their mid-​​30s have been released from prison after serving more than 17 years behind bars for the 1993 mur­ders of three 8-​​year-​​old Cub Scouts in West Mem­phis, Arkansas—a crime that new DNA evi­dence sug­gests they did not commit. We asked Jack Levin, the Brud­nick Dis­tin­guished Pro­fessor of Soci­ology and Crim­i­nology at North­eastern Uni­ver­sity, who spe­cial­izes in the study of vio­lence and hate, to examine the unusual nature of the case.

The case of the West Mem­phis Three has been the sub­ject of a series of HBO doc­u­men­taries and has received sup­port from a number of celebri­ties, including actor Johnny Depp, film­maker Peter Jackson and musi­cian Eddie Vedder. What role did a public call to jus­tice have on the out­come of this case?

Public atten­tion can have an impor­tant impact on a homi­cide case, helping to deter­mine the quality of the inves­ti­ga­tion, the inmate’s length of sen­tence and the deci­sion of a parole board.

On the other hand, the sup­port of well-​​known Hol­ly­wood types kept the case in the spot­light for almost two decades, until DNA analysis could be effec­tively employed to deter­mine whether or not the West Mem­phis Three were con­nected to the crime scene.  The absence of their DNA led to the deci­sion to release them from cus­tody. Lacking in con­tin­uing public pres­sure, it is likely that one of the defen­dants would have been exe­cuted and the others would have served their life sentences.

One member of the West Mem­phis Three mar­ried a woman who ded­i­cated the last 10 years of her life to proving his inno­cence. Why do some inmates gen­erate such a pas­sionate following?

Women who date or marry noto­rious inmates — so-​​called killer groupies — feel that they ben­efit a good deal from their rela­tion­ship. First, they are given a mis­sion or pur­pose — to show the world that their man was a victim of injus­tice. Second, such inmates as the West Mem­phis Three become celebri­ties. Their groupies would love to date a rock star or a rap idol, but any cor­re­spon­dence or phone calls would prob­ably return no more than an auto­graphed photo. Third, a woman who dates an infa­mous man is made to feel impor­tant: The world says that her guy is an evil mon­ster, but he shares his gentle and decent side only with her, so she must be pretty special.

How does an inno­cent person con­victed of murder and then released from prison sev­eral years later go about living a normal life?

There are often family mem­bers and good friends who treat the former inmate with dig­nity and respect — but the public is usu­ally not so kind. What if the judge had erred in releasing the inmates? How do we know that an absence of rea­son­able doubt equates with inno­cence? In the case of the West Mem­phis Three, the con­victed men were never exon­er­ated. In fact, they were made to pro­claim their guilt in order to be released. The stigma of being con­victed of murder usu­ally remains, even when an inmate is deter­mined by the court to be entirely inno­cent of all charges.

– by Jason Kornwitz

More Stories

Photo of the Capitol Building at night

High stakes for politics, SCOTUS in 2018

Photo of the crashed truck that was used in the October 31st attack in Manhattan.

Weaponizing Language: How the meaning of “allahu akbar” has been distorted

Northeastern logo

Why I love studying Spanish