Skip to content

Covid misinformation tests doctors’ free speech rights

People in this story

Bloomberg Law, March 2022

Doctors who have called the Covid vaccine a hoax or say it changes people’s DNA infuriate public health watchdogs, but the First Amendment could protect medical professionals from aggressive attempts by state licensing boards to crack down on false information. Medical professionals speaking outside the context of a one-on-one doctor-patient relationship have traditionally enjoyed the full free-speech protections of the First Amendment. The government must likely show it has good reason—a “compelling interest”—to restrict a doctor’s speech, and that its action is “narrowly tailored” to prevent the harms that could result from the speech.

The goal is to allow doctors to participate freely in public debate, and to prevent the government from imposing a single view of disputed matters, and from overriding the rights of citizens to hear all sides of a debate and come to their own conclusions. Disciplining doctors for public statements will therefore be a matter of “threading the needle,” said Rodney Smolla, dean and professor of law at the Delaware Law School of Widener University, in Wilmington, Delaware. State medical boards will likely be limited to taking action only against “over-the-top statements that no reasonable doctor could make,” he said.

Continue reading at Bloomberg Law.

More Stories

Co-founder Andrew Song of solar geoengineering startup Make Sunsets holds a weather balloon filled with helium, air and sulfur dioxide at a park in Reno, Nevada, United States on February 12, 2023.

Some Politicians Want to Research Geoengineering as a Climate Solution. Scientists Are Worried

Chief Executive Officer of SpaceX and Tesla and owner of Twitter, Elon Musk attends the Viva Technology conference dedicated to innovation and startups at the Porte de Versailles exhibition centre on June 16, 2023 in Paris, France.

You’re Not Supporting Ukraine Enough Until the Nuclear Blast Hits Your Face | Opinion

Picture of Dasani water bottles.

Gov. Healey to sign order banning single-use plastic bottles for state agencies

In the News