Newsweek, November 2026
Democrat Scott Colom pulled off a huge upset in the Mississippi Senate race after every legitimate public poll and well-known political prognosticator favored incumbent Republican Cindy Hyde-Smith, with most classifying the contest as noncompetitive. The race was officially called for Colom on Wednesday, when he led Hyde-Smith by 4,669 votes out of 962,237 counted, or 49.2 percent to 48.7 percent. Before the race was called, Colom had taken issue with well-known political forecaster The Cook Political Report and other “prognosticators,” saying that their ratings made it more difficult to get funding from national Democrats and noting that the South had “been neglected for so long.”
His victory in the deep red South raises two questions. How did analysts communicate uncertainty in such a lightly polled state? And did those ratings discourage investment in a campaign that clearly had a viable path to winning? Before Election Day, Costas Panagopoulos, chair of political science at Northeastern University, told Newsweek that a survey showing one candidate ahead should not be read as a meaningful lead when the candidates’ statistical ranges overlap. “A 48-to-44 race that’s within the margin of error is not necessarily implying a lead for one of the candidates,” Panagopoulos said. “Statistically, it’s a dead heat.” His warning proved especially relevant in Mississippi.