Skip to content

The kingdom stays together

Flag of Scotland

After months of vig­orous cam­paigning from the High­lands to Edin­burgh, Scot­tish cit­i­zens on Thursday shot down a his­toric ref­er­endum that would have made Scot­land an inde­pen­dent country.

Regard­less of Thursday’s out­come, Scot­land get­ting offi­cial say on seceding from the United Kingdom will rever­berate throughout Europe, says assis­tant pro­fessor of polit­ical sci­ence and international affairs Mai’a K. Davis Cross, who closely mon­i­tored the inde­pen­dence referendum.

Early polls leading up to Thursday’s vote, in which about 4.3 mil­lion people were eli­gible to cast a ballot, indi­cated the result would be close. But 55 per­cent of voters ulti­mately said no to the ques­tion “Should Scot­land be an inde­pen­dent country?,” and the nation will con­tinue its union with the United Kingdom.

There are a number of regions in Europe with sim­ilar sit­u­a­tions to Scot­land, Cross explained, such as the Cat­alonian region in Spain or the Flemish-​​speaking region in Bel­gium, that are part of one country but have their own iden­tity and would like to break free.

OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERAThere is a con­cern of a domino effect in parts of Europe,” Cross said. “It could encourage the Basque region or Cat­alonia to say, ‘We would also like inde­pen­dence and maybe join the Euro­pean Union.’”

Aside from the his­toric prece­dence, Cross said what made Thursday’s vote fas­ci­nating is the Euro­pean Union tends to hold regions within member states together because of the tremen­dous amount of sup­port the Euro­pean Union pro­vides to those regions.

Regions get to have a major say in the direc­tion of EU policy, espe­cially on issues such as the pro­tec­tion of their lan­guages, cul­ture, and forms of edu­ca­tion,” Cross said. “Typ­i­cally the dynamic is the EU encour­ages regions like Scot­land to stay with their member state.”

This push for Scot­tish inde­pen­dence began in 2013, when the Scot­tish Par­lia­ment passed a ref­er­endum bill. The pro-​​independence move­ment, Yes Scot­land, believed Scot­tish cit­i­zens are the ones who should make deci­sions about the country’s future, not Eng­land. Better Together, the anti-​​independent cam­paign, looked to main­tain the country’s union with Britain.

Scot­tish inde­pen­dence has been a pop­ular topic of con­ver­sa­tion in Cross’ Euro­pean pol­i­tics courses this semester, and the unprece­dented event could play a role in her research into how cer­tain crises impact Europe.

I think it would be inter­esting to see how some of my work antic­i­pates the out­come of this event,” Cross said. “This is a much smaller crisis com­pared to one like the Euro­zone eco­nomic crisis of 2009, but my argu­ment is these crises tend to make the Euro­pean Union stronger. When it looks like the region might be on the verge of failure, Euro­peans tend to use the crises as oppor­tu­ni­ties to grow stronger.”

Had Scotland’s cit­i­zens voted for inde­pen­dence, Cross said the next expected step was for the country to apply for Euro­pean Union mem­ber­ship. Many believed it could have been the eas­iest step toward mem­ber­ship growth in the union’s his­tory. “Scot­land has already been part of the EU, through the United Kingdom, for decades now,” Cross noted. “It is abiding by all the EU bylaws and regulations.”

– By Joe O’Connell

More Stories

Photo of the Capitol Building at night

High stakes for politics, SCOTUS in 2018

Photo of the crashed truck that was used in the October 31st attack in Manhattan.

Weaponizing Language: How the meaning of “allahu akbar” has been distorted

Northeastern logo

Why I love studying Spanish